Ask three contractors for a gutter price, and you’ll often get three documents that don’t look alike. One quotes a single number. One lists ten items. One prices by the foot and leaves the downspouts as a footnote. That makes gutter costs in Boise hard to compare, even when the work being proposed is nearly the same.
So instead of a list of “factors that affect price,” this post does what we do across a kitchen table: it walks through one sample quote, line by line, and explains what each line means. The sample follows the line-item format we at Idaho Gutter & Shade Solutions recommend asking any contractor for. The dollar figures are highlighted placeholders, because real pricing depends on the house, and we’d rather show you how to read a quote than publish a number that won’t match yours.
The Sample Home
The example is a common Treasure Valley layout: a two-story house with an attached two-car garage, a hip roof over the main house and a gable over the garage.
- 168 linear feet of gutter, including 48 feet on the second story
- 6 downspouts, 3 of them running from the second story
- Existing galvanized steel gutters to be removed
- 2 sections of fascia with soft spots identified during the estimate
The Sample Quote
| Line | Item | Quantity | Price
|
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Remove and haul away existing gutters | 168 ft | [CLIENT TO SUPPLY] |
| 2 | New 5-inch aluminum K-style gutter, formed on site, first story | 120 ft | [CLIENT TO SUPPLY: price per ft] |
| 3 | New 5-inch aluminum K-style gutter, second story | 48 ft | [CLIENT TO SUPPLY: price per ft] |
| 4 | Downspouts with elbows and straps | 6 | [CLIENT TO SUPPLY: price each] |
| 5 | Hidden hangers, fasteners into framing | Included or per ft | [CLIENT TO SUPPLY] |
| 6 | Fascia repair, two sections | Allowance | [CLIENT TO SUPPLY] |
| 7 | Optional: Gutter Topper guards | 168 ft | [CLIENT TO SUPPLY: price per ft] |
| Total before options | [CLIENT TO SUPPLY] |
What Each Line Is Telling You
Line 1: Tear-off
Removal is real labor. Old gutters are often caulked, nailed, and rusted in place, and the crew has to pull them without damaging the drip edge or fascia. A quote that leaves tear-off out isn’t cheaper. It may simply be incomplete, or the removal shows up later as an extra.
Lines 2 and 3: Linear feet, split by story
This is usually the largest line. Splitting first and second story is a detail worth looking for. Second-story work needs taller ladders or staging and more time per foot. If a bid prices everything at one rate, ask whether the height was accounted for.
“Formed on site” means the gutter is run from a coil of flat aluminum through a forming machine at your house, so each run is one continuous piece cut to length. That is what people mean when they search for one-piece gutter cost per foot. Joints exist only at corners and end caps. Our post on what a well-built gutter installation includes explains why that matters for leaks.
Line 4: Downspouts
Downspouts are priced per drop, and second-story drops cost more because they’re longer and need more straps. The count matters more than most homeowners expect. Too few downspouts on a long run is one of the main reasons a new system overflows.
| Field Note: When two bids differ by a lot, count the downspouts first. A pattern worth checking: lower bids sometimes reuse the old downspout locations even when the roof needs an extra drop. The bid looks cheaper, and the overflow problem comes back with the new gutters. |
Line 5: Hangers and fastening
How the gutter is held up is invisible once the job is done, which makes it easy to cut. Hidden hangers screwed through the fascia into the rafter tails hold far better under snow than nails driven into the fascia board alone. Ask what hanger is used, how it’s fastened, and how far apart they’re spaced.
Line 6: Fascia allowance
This is the line that changes. Soft spots seen during the estimate can be bigger than they look once the old gutter comes off.
| The Messy Middle: When the Fascia Is Worse Than Expected
On jobs like this sample, the estimator can only probe the fascia that’s reachable and visible. Once the old gutter is removed, the crew sometimes finds rot running farther along the board, usually behind a seam that leaked for years. The fix is to stop, photograph it, show the homeowner, and agree on the added repair before new gutters go up. A quote with a clear fascia allowance and a stated per-foot rate for extra replacement keeps that conversation simple. A quote with no fascia line at all leaves it open-ended. |
Line 7: Guards as an option
Guards are listed separately so you can see the system price with and without them. Gutter Topper guards are the product we install. Whether guards make sense for your lot depends on your trees and how you feel about ladder work; our comparison of gutter cleaning versus gutter guards walks through that decision. If you plan to keep cleaning instead, our post on gutter cleaning costs and frequency in Boise covers what to budget for that route.
What This Quote Doesn’t Include
A clear quote also tells you what’s outside it. In the sample, that list would include:
- Roof repairs or drip edge replacement, unless written in
- Underground drain lines or work beyond the downspout outlet
- Painting fascia after repair
- Permits, which are not typically required for gutter replacement, though it’s always reasonable to ask
Decision Matrix: Comparing Two Bids
- If one bid has fewer downspouts, then ask each contractor to explain their count for the longest run.
- If one bid prices by the foot and another as a lump sum, then ask the lump-sum bidder for linear footage so you’re comparing the same system.
- If neither bid mentions fascia, then ask how rot found during tear-off will be handled and priced.
- If the gutter sizes differ (5-inch versus 6-inch), then ask why. Larger roofs and steep pitches can justify 6-inch, and it changes the price.
The Bottom Line
The price that matters is the one you won’t have to revisit. Reading a quote line by line protects you from two outcomes: paying for work you didn’t need, and saving money on the parts of a gutter system that fail first. Downspout count, fastening method, and a written fascia allowance are the three lines most likely to separate a lasting install from a short-lived one.
Get Your Own Line-by-Line Estimate
Every house measures differently, so the most accurate number is the one built from your roofline. Our gutter installation and repair services cover tear-off through final cleanup. Request a free estimate, and we’ll walk you through each line of your roof.
About the Author
Idaho Gutter & Shade Solutions is based in Garden City, Idaho, and installs and services gutters and outdoor shade for homes and businesses within about 50 miles of Boise.
- Technical focus: gutter installation, repair, re-sloping, and cleaning; Gutter Topper gutter guards; retractable and patio awnings; StruXure motorized louvered pergolas; Rainier power screens and ClearView retractable screens
- Verified profile: Idaho Gutter & Shade Solutions on Facebook